Redundancy During Coronavirus: Part 2: How Do I Select Employees for Redundancy? 23 April 2020
Redundancy during Coronavirus: Part 2: How do I select employees for redundancy?
In Part 1 of our series of blogs we looked at when a redundancy situation might arise and gave an overview of both individual consultation (where there are fewer than 20 proposed redundancies) and collective consultation (where there are 20 or more proposed redundancies). Employers may now be wondering how employees at risk from redundancy should be selected and the focus of Part 2 is to explain how employers do this using a fair system which does not discriminate against any groups or individuals.
A selection pool is a group of employees from which those that will be placed at risk of redundancy are selected from. Selection pools are not necessary where redundancies arise as a result of the closure of the whole business. Where employers are proposing redundancies as a result of either requiring fewer employees to work of a particular kind or closure of a site then they will need to consider creating selection pools. A failure to do so may result in the subsequent dismissals being deemed unfair.
There are no set rules on how a selection pool should be created. Employers have some flexibility as to how they decide the pool – there is no one size fits all approach – provided they take steps to ensure fairness. However, employers will have to show that they thought about the scope of the pool, for example, is it only those employees in the roles affected that form the selection pool or is the pool widened to include any employees in roles which are similar or interchangeable to the roles affected? In the case of collective redundancies where trade union or employee representatives are involved additional measures may need to be taken around agreeing the pool.
Example: Bedrock Bakery employs 20 employees at its site in Dundee. They are considering proposals to make the bread-bakers in the business redundant due to a reduced demand. However, other bakers in the cake and pastry departments have bread making skills having either been previously trained on bread making or worked in the bread department from time to time to cover holidays. Bedrock Bakery need to carefully consider whether the pool should be made up of only bread-bakers or all bakers across the various departments on the basis the skills are the same, similar or interchangeable. It is important that Bedrock Bakery looks at the work that its employees actually do and the reality of the situation, rather than just what the employees’ contracts say in theory that they may be required to do. Additionally, if Bedrock Bakery has more than one site then they may wish to look at including those in similar roles in other sites in the selection pool because it may be unfair to only include employees at one site within the pool, even if that site is closing completely.
Employers need to ensure that they use reasonable and objective selection criteria when determining which employees from the pool are provisionally selected for redundancy. Employers have discretion over which criteria to choose with the aim of retaining employees who are most valuable to the business. Common criteria include employees’ performance and ability, length of service, attendance records and disciplinary records. Criteria should be measurable and not subjective or based on opinion. Each employee in the pool is then scored against each of the criteria (a weighting system can be applied) and the employees with the lowest scores are provisionally selected for redundancy.
Employers must also be careful not to avoid discrimination in both selecting and applying the selection criteria, for example, because of an employees’ age, gender or if they have a disability. Importantly, in the current climate ACAS has warned employers not to select employees for redundancy simply because they are shielding due to the Coronavirus pandemic as this could be deemed to be disability or age discrimination.
Example: Bedrock Bakery identifies its most important selection criteria as being the quality of work/bake produced by an employee and attendance records. They feel length of service is less important. Each criterion is scored out of 5 but quality is given a weighting of x3 and attendance is given a weighting of x2. Length of service is given a weighting of x1. Everyone is scored using the most up to date appraisals and attendance records and to ensure that no employee who has been absent for a disability-related reason is discriminated against, they decide to discount all disability-related absences. Adopting this strategy ensures only those employees who do not meet the needs of the business are provisionally selected for redundancy and avoids any potential disability discrimination claim.
Conducting the selection process can be challenging for employers however, it is important that they do this correct and fairly. If you are an employer considering redundancies and have any questions then please get in touch with the Blackadders Employment Team.
Duncan Milne, Solicitor
In this section
- General Guidelines
- UK government: Government launches £200m funding for sustainable COVID-19 Business Recovery, 27 June 2020
- Scottish Government: Lockdown begins to ease in Phase 1, 28 May 2020
- Scottish Government: COVID-19 Budget Revision, 27 May 2020
- Scottish Government: Sector Guidance for Easing Lockdown, 26 May 2020
- Scottish Government: COVID-19 Funding Plea, 23 May 2020
- Scottish Government: Expansion of COVID-19 Testing, 18 May 2020
- Data Protection and Privacy During the Coronavirus Pandemic
- Scottish Government: Second Coronavirus (Scotland) Bill, 11 May 2020
- Scottish Government: SME Support Doubles to £90 million, 8 May 2020
- Redundancy during Coronavirus Part 4: How do I calculate redundancy payments?
- Redundancy during Coronavirus: Part 3: How do I consult with employees who are risk of redundancy?
- Scottish Government: Emergency Loan Fund for SME House Builders, 7 May 2020
- UK Government: Business Rates Revaluation Postponed, 6 May 2020
- Scottish Government: New Powers over CAP, 5 May 2020
- Scottish Government: Preparing for Economic Recovery, 5 May 2020
- Uk Government: Self Employed Invited to Get Ready to Make Their Claims for COVID-19 Support, 4 May 2020
- UK Governement: Funding five new testing facilities in Scotland, including Perth, 29 April 2020
- Scottish Government: Rapid Coronavirus Research. More than 50 Scottish Studies to Tackle Virus and its Impact, 28 April 2020
- Scottish Government: Securing Vital COVID-19 Supplies for Scotland, 24 April 2020
- Coronavirus Business Interruption Loan Scheme Update and New Support for Smaller Businesses
- Aberdein Considine: View the latest response to Coronavarius
- Redundancy During Coronavirus: Part 2: How Do I Select Employees for Redundancy? 23 April 2020
- Scottish Government: Lifeline Support for Business Confirmed, 21 April 2020
- Scottish Government: Universal Credit. People Being Urged To Access All Support, 21 April 2020
- Scottish Government: COVID-19 Impact on Scotland's Economy, 21 April 2020
- Redundancy During Coronavirus: Part 1: How Do I Deal With Collective Consultation?, 21 April 2020
- Scottish Government: Call for Accelerated Business Support, 21 April 2020
- UK Government: Billion £ Support Package for Innovative Firms hit by COVID-19, 20 April 2020
- Scottish Government: Extend Brexit Transition during COVID-19 crisis, 20 April 2020
- Scottish Government: Advisory Group on Economic Recovery, 17 April 2020
- Scottish Government: Thousands of Businesses Benefit from Support Grants, 17 April 2020
- UK Government: Chancellor extends furlough scheme to end of June, 17 April 2020
- What Coronavirus Act means for Commerical Landlords
- UK Government: Universal Credit claimants to verify identity through Government Gateway, 16 April 2020
- UK Government: Councils given greater financial relief against cash flow pressures, 16 April 2020
- Scottish Government: Additional Support for Business, including additional £100m for Self-Employed, 15 April 2020
- UK Government: Magnox donates 66,000 items of PPE to support coronavirus response, 15 April 2020
- UK Government: Furlough scheme cut-off date extended to 19 March, 15 April 2020
- UK Government: Job Retention Scheme, 15 April 2020
- Scottish Government: New Mental Health Support, 14 April 2020
- UK Government Response: Commission on Human Medicines: Advice on Ibuprofen and Coronavirus, 14 April 2020
- Scottish Government: National Helpline to Support Those at High COVID-19 Risk, 13 April 2020
- UK Government: Scottish Secretary Welcomes Additional Money to Help Scotland Tackle Coronavirus, 13 April 2020
- Scottish Government: Transport Community to Help COVID-19 Sufferers, 12 April 2020
- Scottish Government: New Measures to Protect Business Tenants, 10 April 2020.
- Scottish Chamber of Commerce: COVID-19 Update
- Scottish Government: Skills matching service to help rural business. 09.04.20
- Scottish Government: Additional COVID-19 Daily Data Published 08.04.20
- UK Government: Coronavirus (COVID-19): letter to the manufacturing sector 08.04.20
- UK Government: Letter from the Secretary of State for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy, Alok Sharma, to those working in retail. 08.04.20
- Scottish Business Community calls for clarity, consistency and cooperation in COVID-19 response 3 April 2020
- Help find new ways too ease global disruption: apply for funding. 3 April 2020
- UK Export Finance to offer export insurance in all major markets in response to Coronavirus (COVID-19). 3 April 2020
- Chancellor strengthens support on offer for business as first government-backed loans reach firms in need
- Scottish Business Community calls for clarity, consistency and cooperation in COVID-19 response. 3 April 2020
- Scottish Govenment Help with non-domestic rates in Scotland during coronavirus (COVID-19) Last updated: 2 April 2020
- Coronavirus: Rishi Sunak announcement on UK government aid for self-employed
- UK Government Self-employment and Universal Credit
- Scottish Government Coronavirus (COVID-19): business and social distancing guidance. Published 25.03.20
- Scottish Government Coronavirus (COVID-19): guidance for businesses on offering support. Published 24 March 2020
- 20th March Update
- SCC & Scottish Government Update 18th March
- SCC & Scottish Government Update 17th March
- PKC Coronavirus (Covid-19) Guidance
- UK Government Coronavirus (Covid-19) Link
- Scottish Government Corona Virus (Covid-19) Link
- NEW Find Business Support in response to Coronavirus - from Scottish Enterprise Source
- Coronavirus: £320m rescue package for business from Scottish government - BBC Sourced
- Guidance & Quick Links
- Helpline announed by Fiona Hyslop, Economy Secretary - Sunday 15th March 2020